Prognostic factors for local and distant recurrence in Stage I and II cervical carcinoma

Abstract

Purpose : The effects of tumor size, parametrial involvement, and other variables on treatment outcome for patients with Federation Internationale de Gynecologie et d'Obsterique (FIGO) Stage I or II cervical carcinoma, as well as treatment complications, were analyzed retrospectively. Methods and Materials : Records of 125 patients with FIGO Stage I or II carcinoma of the uterine cervix selected for curative radiotherapy between January 1980 and December 1990 were reviewed. Twelve patients (9.9%) underwent adjuvant extrafascial hyterectomy and 8 patients (6.4%) received chemotherapy. Median age was 55 years. Median follow-up time was 40 months, and minimum follow-up time was 24 months. The data were analyzed for site of first relapse, survival, overall incidence of complications, and incidence of grade 4 complications. Results : The overall 5-year was: Stage IA: 100%, Stage IB: 72%, Stage IIA: 90%, and Stage IIB: 72%. The 5-year survival with no evidence of disease (NED) was: Stage IA: 100%, Stage IB: 67%, Stage IIA: 90%, and Stage IIB: 50%. Patients with bulky (> 5 cm) tumors had a shorter overall and NED survival than patients with nonbulky tumors (53% vs. 83%; p = 0.0008 and 44% vs. 78%; p = 0.0001, respectively). Thirty-nine tumor recurrences (39 out of 125 = 31%) occurred and were scored as local (23 out of 125 = 18.3%), if initial failure had a local component, or distant (16 out of 125 = 12.7%), if initial failure was distant only. Patients with bulky (more than 5 cm) tumors (32 out of 125) were more likelyto experience a recurrence (18 out of 32 = 56%) than patients with nonbulky tumors (21 out 93 = 22%; p = 0.0004). The initial site of recurrence was more likely to be local for bulky tumors (14 out of 18 = 78%) than for nonbulky tumors (9 out of 21 = 43%; p = 0.03). The profitability of a recurrence increased with the number of involved parametria (none: 20 out of 78 = 25%; one: 12 out 34 = 35%; two 7 out of 13 = 54%; p = 0.04 for linear trend), as did the probability that the initial failure was distant rather than local (none: 4 out of 20 = 20%; one: 7 out of 12 = 58%; two: 5 out of 7 = 71%; p = 0.01 for linear trend). Positive lymph nodes, vessel invasion, and low hemoglobin level all correlated with an increased risk of a recurrence (RR 2.41, p = 0.004; RR 2.20, p = 0.01; OR 2.02, p = 0.01, respectively). There were 46 complications among 37 (29%) patients. The incidence of grade 4 complications was 8.8% (11 out of 125). History of pelvic surgery and bulky tumor were significantly predictors of a grade 4 complications ( p < 0.0001 and 0.021, respectively). Also, a dose rate to point A of > 0.6 Gy/h increased the chance of a grade 4 complication ( p = 0.007). Conclusion : For patients with FIGO Stage I or II cervical carcinoma, tumor size was more predictive of local recurrence than was overall stage, and the extent of parametrical involvement was strongly predictive of distant recurrence, as was the stage. These findings suggest that tumor size and extent of parametrial involvement should be incorporated into the stagling system. Patients with bulky tumors had a shorter survival and were more likely to experience a grade 4 toxicity of therapy. Dose rate to point A of > 0.6 Gy/h was associated with the increased risk of grade 4 complications.