Profiles of Alexandrium catenella cysts in Puget Sound sediments and the relationship to paralytic shellfish poisoning events

Abstract

The magnitude of paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP) toxins in shellfish and the geographical scope of shellfish closures in Puget Sound have increased in recent decades. PSP, monitored by the Washington Department of Health, has spread from Sequim Bay in the 1950s into central Puget Sound in the 1970s and throughout Puget Sound by the 1990s. Alexandrium catenella, the species responsible for PSP toxins, produces a benthic resting cyst that, upon germinating, can seed blooms. This study examined whether there is a relationship between profiles of cysts in the sediment and temporal variation in PSP in shellfish and if the history of the toxin's southward expansion through Puget Sound can be seen in the cyst record. To address this question, sediment cores were collected from three Puget Sound basins, Sequim Bay, Penn Cove, and Carr Inlet, and cyst profiles were determined. Activities of 210Pb were fitted to a depth-dependent diagenetic model to date the sediment cores and determine mixing and sediment-accumulation rates. In order to compare historical variation in PSP with cyst profiles that have been altered by bioturbation, a depth and time-dependent diagenetic model was then used to predict vertical profiles of cysts that would occur under the assumption that cyst deposition rates are proportional to PSP concentration in shellfish measured over several decades at each site. The cyst profiles predicted by the model were compared to measured cyst profiles. These comparisons suggested that Alexandrium blooms and resulting PSP concentration in shellfish are more closely linked to cyst germination and deposition at some stations than at others. Sequim Bay had relatively large numbers of cysts and it is likely that the persistent toxicity here is the result of recurrent seeding from the cyst bed. Penn Cove and Carr Inlet had few cysts despite occasional blooms, suggesting that blooms are transported into those areas, perhaps from other sites of cyst germination. Sequim Bay and Penn Cove had cysts from top to bottom of the cores so it was not possible to determine the date when cysts were first introduced into these bays, but it is likely that A. catenella has been in Penn Cove since at least 1955 or for about two decades before the WDOH PSP toxicity data would indicate. The cyst profile in Carr Inlet suggested a first appearance date of 1985 that is consistent with the first appearance of PSP in shellfish in 1988.