Proficiency testing of pH and electrolytic conductivity measurements of groundwater: a case study of the difference between consensus and metrologically traceable values

Abstract

A proficiency testing (PT) scheme was designed for measurements of pH and electrolytic conductivity (EC) of groundwater in Israel. A groundwater sample was used for preparation of test items fit-for-intended-use. The interlaboratory experiment was organized taking into account changes of the test item properties which occurred after sampling due to presence of CO2 in the groundwater. A total of 34 PT participants reported pH measurements results, while 29 of them reported results of EC measurements. The pH results were normally distributed. However, a significant bias of the pH consensus value of the PT participants from the metrologically traceable certified value (obtained by the National Physical Laboratory of Israel) was detected. This bias was caused by the drift of the measurement response due to water stirring and CO2 degassing from the sample during the measurement process. The bias of the EC consensus value from the metrologically traceable one was negligible, in spite of an abnormal distribution of the EC results of the PT participants.