Abstract

Based on the findings of mixed-methods research conducted with 279 Muslim prisoners in 10 prisons in England, Switzerland and France, this paper argues that contemporary European prisons are sites of intense religious change, in which many people born outside Islam and many born-Muslims believe in and practise Islam for the first time. In order to map this experience of intense religious change in prison, the paper articulates an original typology of conversion to identify Muslim converts as Switchers and Intensifiers. Both of these types of convert mobilise their Islam to turn to God in acts of repentance for their crime(s), to find a renewed purpose in life and to re-gain psychological balance and inner peace. By contrast, a minority of prisoners are Reducers, whose Islamic faith diminishes in prison. A minority of converts to Islam also persist or become more deeply entrenched in the Islamist Worldview of Us vs. Them. Therefore, while choosing to follow Islam in prison carries with it some criminogenic risk, conversion to Islam is significantly more likely to help than to hinder prisoners’ rehabilitation by enabling them to feel remorse for their crimes, reconnecting them with work and education and encouraging them to find emotionally supportive company.

Highlights

  • Contrary to the cynical discourses that prisoners primarily choose to follow Islam for perks, protection and privileges, our research shows that Muslim prisoners are more likely to choose to practise Islam for reasons of piety, emotional coping and good company

  • In a “new” Abrahamic register, many prisoners in European prisons who choose to follow Islam are enacting some of the founding religious penitential purposes of state incarceration, such as repentance, moral reform and a rehabilitative commitment to work and education

  • Switching to and intensification in Islam are significantly connected to improved attitudes to rehabilitation in terms of engagement with work, education and the avoidance of crime

Read more

Summary

Introduction

Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Contrary to the cynical discourses that prisoners primarily choose to follow Islam for perks, protection and privileges, our research shows that Muslim prisoners are more likely to choose to practise Islam for reasons of piety, emotional coping and good company. These largely sincere motives for choosing to follow Islam impact in a significantly positive knock-on way on prisoners’ attitudes to rehabilitation in terms of a reconnection with work, education and an intention to avoid future crime

Mass Muslim Migration Leads to Mass Muslim Imprisonment
The Over-Representation of Muslims in Prison
The Real and “Imagined” Link between Islam in Prison and Terrorism
Growing Islamic Virtues in Prison
Religious Conversion in Prison
Extra-Faith and Inter-Faith Conversion
Intra-Faith Conversion
Cynical Interpretations of Religious Conversion in Prison
Generating the Empirical Data
Theoretical Framework
An Original Typology of Conversion
Methodology
Ethics
Recruitment
Analysis
Prison Categories and Types
Socio-Demographic and Basic Religious Description of the Sample
Denominational affiliation within
Significant
F R Afirst
55 Muslim prisoners from five Swiss prisons
34 Muslim prisoners:
The significance of “Engagement with Chaplaincy”
Different Quality of “Engagement with Chaplaincy” across Jurisdictions
Reasons for Switching to or Intensifying in Islam in Prison
The Views of Muslim Prisoners
The Views of Prison Officers
The Evidence and Effects of Piety
Making Repentance and Seeking God’s Forgiveness through Obligatory Prayer
Regaining Balance and Calm
Finding Purpose
Structuring Time
The Evidence and Effects of Good Company
10. The Rehabilitative Tendency Inherent in Conversion to and within Islam
10.2. Reading and Education
11. The Islamist Risk Inherent in Switching to and Intensifying in Islam
12. The Reducers
Findings
13. Summary
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call