Primitive arc magma diversity: New geochemical insights in the Cascade Arc

Abstract

The origin of the large range of compositional diversity encompassed by primitive arc magmas and the respective roles of mantle heterogeneity versus slab-derived contributions are the center of ongoing debate. The Cascade Arc of western North America is a global endmember hot subduction zone and an ideal setting in which to examine fundamental questions about the origin of arc magmas. Cascade Arc primitive magmas define several distinct compositional endmembers, the most widespread of which are high alumina olivine tholeiite (HAOT), calc-alkaline basalt (CAB), and intraplate-type basalt (IPB). New high precision Sr-Nd-Hf-Pb isotopic and trace element data for 49 of the most primitive magmas from seven major High Cascades volcanic centers are used to assess whether the basalt groups are derived from geochemically distinct mantle sources. Along with recently published data for the Garibaldi Volcanic Belt (GVB), the northern and other major segment of the Cascade Arc, and Mt. Rainier, the new data expand the high-precision isotopic coverage to seventeen volcanic centers spanning the ~1300km length of the arc. In all investigated isotopic systems, the new High Cascades data allow for finer resolution with much less scatter than previous data. HAOT mantle sources are systematically more depleted in incompatible elements than CAB sources, yet High Cascades CABs and HAOTs are isotopically indistinguishable, defining a remarkable linear Pb isotopic array consistent with a single mantle endmember that is similar to the source of Juan de Fuca mid-ocean ridge basalts. This mantle has been variably modified by contributions from a single subducting sediment endmember that is a close isotopic match to average Northern Cascadia basin sediment. Although Astoria Fan sediment was previously used as a proxy for the subducting sediment composition in the Cascadia subduction zone, the isotope ratios of Cascades basalts record no input from Astoria Fan sediment. High Cascades CABs and HAOTs both contain subducting sediment input in the form of a melt, but CABs also contain melts of subducting oceanic crust which is most apparent in the southern Cascades high-Sr/P suite and in the GVB. The least sediment input is recorded by GVB basalts, which also become progressively lower in 208Pb*/206Pb* and Hf isotope ratios to the north, reflecting the influx of an isotopically distinct enriched mantle component that generates IPBs at the northern slab edge. Enriched mantle with a composition trending towards HIMU is also recorded by a distinct isotopic array that is defined by IPBs from the Mt. Adams-Simcoe back arc region. We propose that slab gaps permit the influx of sub-slab asthenospheric mantle in both the northern GVB and Mt. Adams-Simcoe back-arc. Otherwise, western North America is underlain predominantly by isotopically homogeneous, MORB-type depleted mantle from which both the CAB and HAOT basalt groups are derived. Our results from the Cascades imply that most of the compositional heterogeneity encompassed by primitive arc magmas is not related to the presence of multiple mantle components but to variability in the composition and quantity of slab contributions. This study highlights the importance of high precision Sr-Nd-Hf-Pb isotope and trace element data in obtaining new insights on the petrogenesis of arc magmas.