Prevalence and Pattern of Lateral Impingements in the Progressive Collapsing Foot Deformity

Abstract

Category:Hindfoot; Midfoot/ForefootIntroduction/Purpose:Lateral impingements, subdivided into Sinus Tarsi (STI), Talo-Fibular (TFI), and Calcaneo-Fibular (CFI) impingements, appear to be associated with the Peritalar Subluxation (PTS) component of the Progressive Collapsing Foot Deformity (PCFD). This is not yet confirmed, as the chronological place of the different types of lateral impingements in PTS is unknown. It is also unclear whether STI are associated with PTS or Midfoot Abduction. Our primary objective was to assess the amount of PTS in STI, TFI and CFI. Our secondary objective was to determine the position of STI among the PTS and Midfoot Abduction deformities. We hypothesized that STI and TFI will be associated with a lower amount of PTS than CFI and that STI will be part involved in both PTS and Midfoot Abduction deformities.Methods:A retrospective study including 72 PCFD assessed with Weight Bearing Computed Tomography (WBCT) was realized. Patients under 15 or with a previous history of surgery were excluded. Lateral impingements were assessed on WBCT images and subdivided as STI, TFI and CFI. Both direct and indirect signs of impingement were considered positive. The amount of PTS was assessed by the percentage of uncoverage and the incongruence angle of the Middle Facet (MF). Midfoot-Abduction was assessed by Talonavicular coverage angle and global foot deformity by Foot and Ankle Offset (FAO). These data were collected by two independent observers and one performed a blinded second assessment. Interobserver and Intraobserver reliabilities were determined using unweighted Cohen's kappa values for lateral impingements and using intraclass correlation coefficients for the measurements. Impingement groups were compared using Student's T-tests for normal, and Mann-Whitney for non-normal variables.Results:Interobserver and Intraobserver reliabilities ranged from substantial to almost perfect for all assessments. STI was present in 84.7%, TFI in 65.2% and CFI in 19.4% of PCFD cases. PCFD with STI showed significant increases of MF uncoverage (p=0.0001), FAO (p=0.0008) and Talonavicular coverage angle (p=0.0197) compared to PCFD without STI. PCFD with TFI did not show significant difference on measurements compared to PCFD without TFI. PCFD with CFI had associated STI in 100% and TFI in 64.2% of cases. PCFD with CFI showed significant decreases of MF incongruence (p=0.0398) and significant higher FAO (p=0.0058) compared to PCFD without CFI. PCFD with both STI and CFI showed significant decreases of MF incongruence (p=0.032) and significant higher FAO (p=0.028) compared to PCFD with isolated STI.Conclusion:Our hypotheses have not been confirmed. STI was associated with both PTS and Midfoot Abduction deformities but neither TFI nor CFI were associated with PTS considering MF subluxation. Conversely, CFI was associated with a reduction of the MF incongruence angle despite being associated with a higher global deformity. STI may be associated with earlier PCFD with a concentration of the malignment forces in the subtalar joint whereas CFI may occur later and be associated with a failure of the deep layer of the deltoid ligament and a talar tilt. This could explain the relative reduction of the PTS in CFI.