Pressure dependent trace gas trapping in amorphous water ice at 77 K: Implications for determining conditions of comet formation

Abstract

The nature of cometary volatile materials is subject to debate. Theoretical models of cometary nuclei and laboratory studies suggest that these objects could be made of amorphous water ice in addition to other volatile molecules and refractory grains. This water ice structure has the ability to encapsulate the gases of surrounding environment, reflecting the physical and chemical conditions during their deposition. Therefore, the knowledge of the chemical composition of volatile molecules trapped in amorphous water ice provides a tool for probing the formation environment of cometary ice grains. Experimental studies of gas trapping efficiency in amorphous water ice have been previously conducted mostly under kinetic conditions, where dynamic pumping and temperature gradients prevented rigorous calibrations. In this work, we investigated the trapping efficiencies of Ar, CO, CH4, Kr and N2 by depositing water vapor as ice in the presence of trace gases in a volume submerged in liquid nitrogen at 77K. The gas trapping efficiencies were determined simply by monitoring the pressure difference of the trace gases before and after the deposition of a known amount of water molecules as amorphous ice.Our results show that the trapped gas to water molecule ratio in amorphous ice is controlled primarily by the partial pressure of the gas during water ice deposition, and is independent of the ice deposition rate as well as the gas to water ratio in the vapor phase. The trapping efficiencies of gases decrease in the order of Kr>CH4>CO>Ar>N2 in accordance with previous studies. Assuming that the water ice structure of comets is at least partially amorphous water ice at the time of their formation, these results suggest that the total pressure and composition of the surrounding environment of amorphous ice formation are significant controlling factors of trace gas concentrations in cometary ice. This further indicates that the evolution of the solar nebula and timing of cometary ice condensation can also be important parameters in linking the volatile contents of comets and their formation process.