Preference Prediction for the Stable Inclusion Complexes between Cyclodextrins and Monocyclic Insoluble Chemicals Based on Monte Carlo Docking Simulations

Abstract

Cyclodextrins (CDs) are useful functional excipients, which are being used to camouflage undesirable pharmaceutical characteristics, especially poor aqueous solubility, through the inclusion complexation process with insoluble drugs. The selection of more efficient cyclodextrin is important to improve the bioavailability of drugs. In this study, the complexing and solubilizing abilities toward poorly water-soluble monocyclic molecules of natural CDs (α-CD, β-CD, and γ-CD) were investigated using Monte Carlo (MC) docking simulations studies. These theoretical results closely agree with the experimental observation of the complex stability in water of the various guests–CD complexes. Host preferences, based on the experimentally determined stability constants between host CDs and guest molecules, show excellent correlation with the calculated interaction energies of corresponding complexes. The inclusion complex with the lower MC docking interaction energy shows a higher value of stability constant than that of the other complex, and the prediction accuracy of the preferred complex for 21 host–guest pairs is 100%. This result indicates that the MC docking interaction energy could be employed as a useful parameter to select more efficient cyclodextrin as a host for the bioavailability of insoluble drugs. In this study, β-CD shows greater solubilizing efficacies toward guest molecules than those of α-CD and γ-CD, with the exception of one case due to the structure of a guest molecule containing one lipophilic cyclic moiety. The surface area change of CDs and hydrogen bonding between the host and guest also work as major factors for the formation of the stable complex.