Predictors of Large Labral Tears: A Multicenter Orthopaedic Outcomes Network (MOON) Shoulder Instability Cohort Study

Abstract

Objectives:Labral tears are often described by either their location (superior, anterior, or posterior) or their size, commonly defined as degrees of labral involvement from 0° to 360°. Large tears are thought to include 270° or more of the labrum, which has been reported to include 3.3% to 6.5% of those undergoing shoulder instability surgery for labral pathology. Demographic or injury characteristics of those with large labral tears (>270°) has not been defined in the literature. The purpose of this study was to identify factors predictive of a large labral tear at the time of shoulder instability surgery.Methods:As part of the Multicenter Orthopaedic Outcomes Network (MOON) Shoulder Instability cohort, patients undergoing open or arthroscopic shoulder instability surgery for a labral tear were evaluated. Those with an isolated SLAP (superior labrum anterior to posterior) tear or a concomitant rotator cuff tear requiring repair were excluded. Demographic data, injury history, preoperative patient-reported outcome scores (PROs), imaging and intraoperative findings, and surgical procedures performed were recorded. The treating surgeon reported the size and location of labral pathology visualized at the time of surgery. Patients with greater than a 270° tear were defined as having a large labral tear. For categorical demographic variables, a chi-square test or Fisher’s Exact test was used, as appropriate based on cell counts. For continuous demographic variables, a two-sample t-test was performed. In order to build a predictive logistic regression model for large tears, the Feasible Solutions Algorithm (Lambert et al. 2018) was used to add significant interaction effects iteratively until no more significant two-way interactions could be added to the model.Results:After applying exclusion criteria, 1235 patients were available for analysis. There were 222 females (18.0%) and 1013 males (82.0%) in the cohort with an average age of 24.7 years old (12 – 66 years old). The incidence of large tears was 4.6% with the average tear size being 141.9°, or 39.4%. Males accounted for significantly more of the large tears seen in the cohort (94.7%, p = 0.01). Racquet sports (p = 0.002), swimming (p = 0.02), softball (p = 0.05), skiing (p = 0.04), and golf (p = 0.04) were all found to be predictive of large labral tears as was a higher Western Ontario Shoulder Instability (WOSI) score (p = 0.01) (Table 1). Patients with a larger body mass index (BMI) who played contact sports were also more likely to have large tears (p = 0.007). Age, race, history of dislocation, injury during sport, or previous shoulder surgery were not associated with having a larger tear.Conclusion:Patients with large labral tears are a small, but not insignificant, subset of patients undergoing shoulder instability surgery. Multiple factors were identified as being associated with large labral tears at the time of surgery including male sex, pre-operative WOSI score, and participation in certain sports including racquet sports, softball, skiing, swimming, and golf. Surgeons treating patients with these risk factors should be prepared to encounter a large labral tear at the time of surgery. Further studies will evaluate the outcomes of this patient population.Table 1.Comparison of patient demographics and sport history between shoulder instability patients with large labral tears (>270°).Small Tears (<270°)Large Tears(>270°)PN1178 (95.4%)57 (4.6%)-Sex (F, M (%F))219,959 (81.4% M)3, 54 (94.7% M)0.01Age24.69.0265.9.70.13Injury During Sport836 (71.0%)42 (73.7%)0.74Racquet Sport46 (3.9%)7 (12.3%)0.002Swimming205 (17.4%)17 (29.8%)0.02Softball114 (9.7%)10 (17.5%)0.05Skiing206 (17.5%)16 (28.1%)0.04Golf225 (19.0%)17 (19.8%)0.04