Predictive Value of Laryngeal Penetration to Aspiration in a Cohort of Pediatric Patients.

Abstract

Videofluoroscopic swallow studies (VFSS) provide dynamic assessment of the phases of swallowing under fluoroscopic visualization and allow for identification of abnormalities in the process, such as laryngeal penetration and aspiration. While penetration and aspiration both reflect degrees of swallowing dysfunction, the predictive potential of penetration for subsequent aspiration is not fully elucidated in the pediatric population. As a result, management strategies for penetration vary widely. Some providers may interpret any depth or frequency of penetration as a proxy for aspiration and implement various therapeutic interventions (e.g., modification of liquid viscosity) to eliminate penetration episodes. Some may recommend enteral feeding given the presumed risk of aspiration with penetration, even when aspiration is not identified during the study. In contrast, other providers may advise continued oral feeding without modification even when some degree of laryngeal penetration is identified. We hypothesized that the depth of penetration is associated with the likelihood of aspiration. Identification of predictive factors for aspiration following laryngeal penetration events has significant implications for selection of appropriate interventions. We performed a retrospective cross-sectional analysis of a random sample of 97 patients who underwent VFSS in a single tertiary care center over a 6month period. Demographic variables including primary diagnosis and comorbidities were analyzed. We examined the association between aspiration and degrees of laryngeal penetration (presence or absence, depth, frequency) across diagnostic categories. Infrequent and shallow penetration events of any type of viscosity were less likely to be associated with aspiration event(s) during the same clinical encounter regardless of diagnosis. In contrast, children with consistent deep penetration of thickened liquids invariably demonstrated aspiration during the same study. Our findings show that shallow, intermittent laryngeal penetration of any viscosity type on VFSS was not consistent with clinical aspiration. These results provide further evidence that penetration-aspiration is not a uniform clinical entity and that nuanced interpretation of videofluoroscopic swallowing findings is necessary to guide appropriate therapeutic interventions.