Predation on planted and wild bay scallops (Argopecten irradians irradians) by busyconine whelks: studies of behavior incorporating acoustic telemetry

Abstract

Quantifying predator–prey interactions and gaining insights into predator behavior are crucial for optimizing restoration strategies. However, such knowledge is often lacking for marine invertebrates. We examined potential impacts of predation by channeled Busycotypus canaliculatus and knobbed whelks Busycon carica on natural and planted populations of bay scallops in the Peconic Bays, New York, through laboratory and field investigations. In lab experiments, mean predation rates exhibited by small channeled whelks were low: 0.06 and 0.005 scallops d−1 for adult and juvenile scallops, respectively. Predation rates of small knobbed whelks on juvenile scallops were 22 × higher. Eighty-six percent (86%) of scallops consumed by channeled whelks had undamaged shells, while 73% eaten by knobbed whelks had notched ventral margins. In field plots where scallop densities were manipulated via removals/plantings, whelks consumed ~ 2% of ~ 19,100 planted juveniles, whereas crabs and presumably finfish consumed > 40% overall. Acoustic telemetry revealed that tagged channeled whelks moved shorter distances and spent more time in plots planted with scallops versus those without scallops. Whelks spent more time in low versus high-density plots, but consumed far more scallops in the latter. In trials without scallops, whelk movement rates were 5 × higher, presumably due to increased exploratory behavior. Overall, whelks were most active during crepuscular hours and during periods of increasing wind speeds. Our results, combined with population abundance data, suggest that whelks (especially B. carica) are drawn to planted bay scallop aggregations, but probably contribute to relatively low overall mortality in the context of restoration efforts.