Precision of Ages Determined from Scales and Opercles for Yellow Perch Perca flavescens

Abstract

Scales and opercles were used to age yellow perch Perca flavescens collected in 1989 from Lake Madison (South Dakota), Dauphin Lake (Manitoba), and southern Lake Michigan (Indiana). Three readers aged fish from Lake Madison and Dauphin Lake once and two readers aged fish from Lake Michigan twice. The coefficient of variation (CV) was calculated to compare precision. Ages determined from opercles were as precise as those from scales for fish from Lake Madison ( CV = 0 for both structures), and more precise than ages from scales for fish from Dauphin Lake ( CV opercle = 14.0, CV scale = 27.4, p < 0.001) and Lake Michigan ( CV opercle = 10.6, CV scale = 13.9, p < 0.001). The high precision of scale and opercle ages for yellow perch from Lake Madison can be attributed to the fast growth rate of fish from that lake and also that only age 1 and 2 fish were aged. The greater precision of opercle ages in comparison to scale ages for Dauphin Lake and Lake Michigan yellow perch can be attributed to ease of recognition of false annuli on opercles as well as to difficulty in distinguishing between false and true annuli crowded on the edge of scales from mature, slower growing fish. Because true annuli are more easily recognized on opercles, ages determined from opercles may be more accurate than ages determined from scales for yellow perch growing at slow or moderate rates.