Potential loss of nutrients, carbon and metals in simulated runoff associated with dairy processing sludge application

Abstract

Dairy processing wastewater treatment sludge (DPWTS) is applied to grassland to recycle valuable nutrients and organic matter. Until recently the chemical composition of the dominant DPWTS types (calcium, aluminium or iron rich) was unknown, but the latest study (Ashekuzzaman et al. in J Clean Prod 230:1266–1275, 2019) indicates that DPWTS has high nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) content and their inherent chemical properties may influence their availability and losses. Herein for the first time edge of field-losses and plant-available P changes are simulated in an agitator test 48 h after application. In terms of overall losses, metals are not of concern across treatment types, iron-rich DPWTS has the highest losses in terms of concentration of ammonium-N and carbon, whereas calcium-rich DPWTS has the highest dissolved reactive P (DRP) losses but lowest losses of ammonium-N and carbon. The loss of DRP was found to be strongly positively associated with the increase in water-extractable P, degree of P saturation, Morgan’s and Mehlich-3 extractable phosphorus (Pm, M3-P), respectively. Runoff concentrations presented here represent edge of field-losses and may not represent final concentrations entering a surface waterbody. In terms of plant-available P, there were no negative effects with Pm exhibiting a positive trend across DPWTS types and soils. In particular, a significant increase was found for the calcium-rich DPWTS across all soils (average increase in Pm by fivefold). As applying DPWTS to grassland is an understudied area, further field trials should focus on emissions to air and water and examine the fertilizer value from N and P perspectives. Thus a better management of DPWTS as fertiliser can be maintained from an agronomic and environmental context.