Potency evaluation of rabies vaccine for human use: The impact of reducing the number of animals per dilution – Part 2

Abstract

The most critical parameter for the quality control of the rabies vaccine is potency, which is evaluated by challenge test in mice while using a large animal number. Because the 3Rs concept is applied worldwide, it becomes necessary to develop alternative methods to demonstrate the production consistency of these vaccines and reduce the number of animals used for performing assays. Hence, the present study evaluated the impacts of reducing the number of mice used in the NIH test for such vaccines. A retrospective data analysis compared vaccines tested in the standard test with the results of the reduced test using only the first cages of each dilution and considering the second cages as their replicates. The relevance of the reduced assay was evaluated using Bland- Altman plot and CCC. Reliability was assessed by CV% and confidence intervals, while the impact of the reduced mouse number was evaluated by the analysis of the confidence interval of potency results and regression, linearity and parallelism parameters. The results demonstrated the feasibility of reducing to eight mice per dilution in routine assays, with complete statistical validation of the resulting potency, allowing the number of animals used for the test vaccines to be reduced by 50%.