Post-oncological full-thickness eyelid defect reconstruction: An aesthetical overview

Abstract

Purpose of the current study was to introduce a new detailed aesthetical subunit (ASU) involvement chart to localize the defect configuration on the eyelids, and, to evaluate the aesthetical and functional outcomes of the post-oncological full-thickness eyelid defect reconstruction surgery by using a modified aesthetical rating guideline.Medical records of subjects who were diagnosed with a primary malignant full thickness eyelid tumor involving the eyelid margin and underwent full-thickness eyelid defect reconstruction surgery between April 2016 and May 2022 were retrospectively reviewed. Age, sex, pathological diagnosis, follow-up time, the ASU of the eyelid involvement, and surgical methods used to reconstruct the anterior and posterior lamella were examined from medical records. The reconstructed eyelid photos were scored according to the modified aesthetical rating guideline to analyze the aesthetical and functional outcomes of the surgeries.A total of 31 subjects were included to the study, and the overall mean aesthetical score was 3.5. Seventeen subjects with aesthetical scores greater than 3.5 were included in the more aesthetically pleasing (AP) group, and 14 subjects with aesthetical score less than 3.5 were included in less AP group. Anterior lamella repair was mainly performed using myo-cutaneous flaps in the more AP group and multiple flap combinations in the less AP group (P: 0.13). Posterior lamella reconstruction was performed using tarso-conjunctival tissue in both groups. In more AP group, tissue scarring, lash line disruption, eyelid thickness, and retraction or ectropion scores were significantly higher when compared with less AP group (P:0.03, P:0.03, P:0.02, and P:0.01, respectively). Subjects with fair eyelash color were significantly more common in more AP group (P: 0.009).The ASU involvement chart and outcomes of the current study may aid novice surgeons to determine which method will provide the best result for an individual patient for full-thickness eyelid defect repair and may offer some insight into the different surgical techniques used for repairing similar wounds.