Post-fire growth of Pinus halepensis: Shifts in the mode of competition along a precipitation gradient

Abstract

Competition can intensify the struggle for resources among plants, affecting forest growth and dynamics. The intensity and mode of competition – asymmetric vs. symmetric – can change along environmental gradients and with time, impacting the response of plants to their environment, but this is seldom explicitly considered in management plans. In this study, we aim to (i) disentangle the main environmental and tree-related factors that affect post-fire Pinus halepensis sapling growth; (ii) determine which mode of competition characterizes the species post-fire regeneration; and (iii) elucidate if the mode of competition changes with time, and along climatic gradients. We sampled 148 P. halepensis saplings located in 15 sites affected by wildfires between 1987 and 2013 in Catalonia (NE Spain). We measured their radial growth at the base, and we identified their competitive environment by locating and measuring all the trees in a 3-meter-radius from our target saplings. We modelled the effect of tree size, age, climate, and competitive environment on the post-fire regeneration growth following the neighborhood theory of forest dynamics and using model comparison and information criteria to address our research questions. We used a modification from the Hegyi index to determine the prevalence of symmetric vs. asymmetric competition, and we assessed the support for models in which competition was allowed to vary with age and precipitation. The best model showed that competition, precipitation, age, and target size influenced the radial growth of P. halepensis post-fire regeneration (Akaike weight 0.66, R2 = 0.52). We found evidence that P. halepensis mode of competition is generally asymmetric but can change along a precipitation gradient: it shifts from asymmetric in drier sites to almost fully symmetrical as precipitation increases. Our findings have implications for the management of post-fire P. halepensis stands, enabling the adaptation of silvicultural prescriptions to the climatic environment. In a context of increasing water scarcity, adaptive silviculture is fundamental to foster the resilience of pinewoods to future climatic and disturbance regimes.