Possible evidence for panspermia: the labelled release experiment

Abstract

Abstract30 years after the Viking Mission landed on Mars (20 July 1976) to search for life, despite the positive findings of the Labelled Release (LR) experiment, the issue remains unresolved. The controversial history, following the immediate dismissal of the LR’s evidence for microbial activity in the Martian soil, and the later claim to its having found living microorganisms are reviewed. The bearing of post-Viking-to-current data on the issue is discussed in the context of the scientific community’s growing interest in the long-dismissed possibility of microbial life on Mars. Objections raised over the years to the biological interpretation of the Mars LR, those currently maintained, and their rebuttals are reviewed. A case is presented that enough evidence now exists for an objective review by astrobiologists to resolve this key issue, a review, surprisingly, not yet held. The results could greatly influence NASA’s currently shifting plans for Mars exploration. A variation of the LR experiment to test for chiral specificity in the metabolism of substrates by the active agent found in the Martian soil, and thus having the capability of obtaining an unambiguous answer to the life question, is proposed. Confirmation of life on Mars by this experiment can also determine whether Martian and Earth life forms share a common heritage. Together with mounting evidence for the viable transfer of microorganisms between the two planets, this would be evidence for panspermia, and establish the presence of a common biosphere in which the two planets participate. Should Martian microorganisms show a different chiral specificity than that of Earth life then this would indicate separate origins of the two neighbouring life forms, thereby strongly implying that life occurs widely throughout the cosmos. Any one of these possible outcomes would be a paradigm-breaking event.