Population Dynamics and Simulated Effects of Length‐Based Trophy Regulations for Flathead and Channel Catfish in the Lower James River, South Dakota

Abstract

AbstractCatfish are popular with anglers fishing southeastern South Dakota rivers, and a group of anglers has expressed concern about the perceived overharvest of trophy‐size catfish. However, existing data are insufficient for determining whether Flathead Catfish Pylodictis olivaris and Channel Catfish Ictalurus punctatus are being overharvested. Our objective was to determine the population dynamics of Flathead and Channel catfish and model potential outcomes of length‐based trophy regulations (one fish and no fish harvested over 610 mm) in the lower James River, South Dakota. Multiple gears were used to collect Flathead Catfish (low‐frequency electrofishing and trotlines) and Channel Catfish (baited hoop nets and low‐frequency electrofishing) during 2018, and samples were augmented with angler‐caught catfish collected from three angling tournaments. Pectoral spines were removed from a subsample of fish for age estimation; 305‐mm and larger fish received a Carlin dangler tag with a reward value of US$0, $10, or $100. Growth rates were slow to moderate for Flathead Catfish and moderate for Channel Catfish. Trophy‐size Flathead Catfish (TL ≥ 1,020 mm) were sampled, but few of the collected Channel Catfish exceeded preferred length (TL ≥ 610 mm). Total annual mortality was estimated at 25.7% for Flathead Catfish and 25.2% for Channel Catfish. Exploitation estimated from angler reward tag returns was less than 1% for each species. Yield‐per‐recruit models indicated that a regulation specifying one fish over 610 mm would slightly reduce yield for both species but would only increase the number of memorable‐length Flathead Catfish (860 mm) and Channel Catfish (710 mm) by less than 1%. A no‐harvest regulation would substantially reduce yield of Flathead Catfish and would increase the number of memorable‐length Flathead Catfish by approximately 2% and Channel Catfish by less than 1%. Information obtained during this study suggests that current Flathead and Channel Catfish populations have limited trophy potential and that length‐based trophy regulations would have limited impact on the abundance of large catfish in the lower James River.