Poor adherence to staging guidelines for children with malignant ovarian tumors

Abstract

PurposeHistorically, surgical staging practices for pediatric malignant ovarian tumors mirrored adult guidelines. In 2004, the Children's Oncology Group (COG) developed guidelines specific to pediatric patients with ovarian germ cell tumors. We sought to characterize the operative management of pediatric ovarian lesions and adherence to COG surgical staging guidelines. MethodsWe conducted a single institution, retrospective study of pediatric patients who underwent surgical intervention for ovarian lesions between 1995 and 2012. The primary outcome was adherence to COG staging guidelines. ResultsAmong 502 patients, 44 (8.8%) had malignant ovarian tumors. Two patients (2/44, 4.5%) underwent correct surgical staging. Therefore, 95.5% (42/44) underwent incorrect surgical staging by omitting recommended maneuvers (surgical understaging) or performing clinically unnecessary surgical staging steps (surgical overstaging). Of the 42 patients with incorrect surgical staging, 85.7% (36/42) were surgically overstaged and 76.2% (32/42) were surgically understaged. In the entire cohort, 12 (27.3%) patients had complete staging procedures, including 10 surgically overstaged patients (10/12, 83.3%). Staging practices were not significantly different before and after the release of the 2004 COG guidelines. ConclusionIncorrect surgical staging of pediatric ovarian malignancies is commonplace. These data stress the need for greater education among all surgeons caring for children with malignant ovarian tumors.