Platy Talc, Asbestos, and Talc Fibers in the Female Genital Tract in Patients with Ovarian Cancer

Abstract

Abstract Introduction/Objective Recent analyses on human tissue help inform the discussion regarding talc and ovarian cancer, by showing that, in some patients, considerable talc can migrate to multiple organ sites in the pelvic region from perineal application. Recently, we showed that birefringent particles were seen by polarized light microscopy and shown to be talc by scanning electron microscopy/energy dispersive X-ray analysis (SEM/EDS) and/or Raman spectroscopy in surgically resected tissues from patients with ovarian carcinoma and perineal talc exposure. These sites included ovary, cervix, fallopian tube, uterine serosa, and regional lymph nodes. Fibrous talc, with greater carcinogenic potential as determined by the International Agency for Research on Cancer, may be observed in pelvic tissues. Besides ascension through the reproductive tract, particles and fibers may gain entry to pelvic organs by accessing small submucosal lymphatics in the lower part of the tract. Both platy and fibrous talc have an Mg-Si elemental signature, weight % Mg/Si ratio within 5% of the theoretical value of 0.649, and thus are distinguishable from other exogenous substances including the various subtypes of asbestos. Methods Tissue-based analytic methods (including in situ SEM, where a paraffin block is examined directly under variable pressure) are critical in the detection of talc and asbestos, particularly since they preserve architecture, and demonstrate talc and/or fibrous particles within their histologic environment; this may help inform exposure origin and pathophysiologic significance. Results We reviewed the analytic outcomes of our consultative experience to date. This showed that 180 of 196 patients with a history of perineal talc exposure had birefringent particles seen by light microscopy in surgically resected pelvic tissues, and 82 of 91 had talc confirmed by SEM/EDS. Carcinogenic fibers were found in 28/82 (34%) of these patients, with talc fibers only (19/82 patients, 23%), asbestos (7/82, 9%) or both (2/82, 2%) confirmed by SEM/EDS. Conclusion Our study confirms that talc and toxic fibers may be found in human pelvic tissues of talc-exposed patients. Because the SEM/EDS method samples only a small amount of tissue relative to what is in the paraffin block, the finding of exogenous particles by this method typically translates to a high overall particle burden, when scaled mathematically to bulk tissue.