Plate tectonics in the twenty-first century

Abstract

Plate tectonics was originally established as a kinematic theory of global tectonics, in which the Earth’s rigid outer layer, the lithosphere, consists of different size plates that move relative to each other along divergent, convergent or transform boundaries overlying the ductile asthenosphere. It comprises three elements: rigid lithosphere plates, ductile asthenosphere, and coupled movement systems. It operates through the interlinked processes of continental drift, seafloor spreading and lithospheric subduction, resulting in the generation, modification and demise of lithospheres throughout geological time. The system of lithospheric plates in horizontal and vertical movements forms the spatiotemporal linkages of matter and energy between the surface and interior of Earth, advancing the kinematic theory with a dynamic explanation. While top-down tectonics through lithospheric subduction plays a key role in the operation of plate tectonics, it is balanced for the conservation of both mass and momentum on the spherical Earth by bottom-up tectonics through asthenospheric upwelling to yield seafloor spreading after continental breakup. The gravity-driven subduction of cool lithosphere proceeds through convergence between two plates on one side, and rollback of the subducting slab makes the vacancy for upwelling of the hotter asthenosphere to form active rifting in backarc sites. Plate convergence is coupled with plate divergence between two plates along mid-ocean ridges on the other side, inducing passive rifting for seafloor spreading as a remote effect. Thus, plate tectonics is recognizable in rock records produced by tectonic processes along divergent and convergent plate margins. Although the asthenospheric upwelling along fossil suture zones may result in continental breakup, seafloor spreading is only induced by gravitational pull of the subducting oceanic slab on the remote side. Therefore, the onset and operation of plate tectonics are associated with a series of plate divergent-convergent coupling systems, and they are critically dependent on whether both construction and destruction of plates would have achieved and maintained the conservation of both mass and momentum on the spherical Earth. Plate margins experience different types of deformation, metamorphism and magmatism during their divergence, convergence or strike-slip, leaving various geological records in the interior of continental plates. After plate convergence, the thickened lithosphere along fossil suture zones in intracontinental regions may be thinned by foundering. This causes the asthenospheric upwelling to reactivate the thinned lithosphere, resulting in superimposition and modification of the geological record at previous plate margins. The operation of plate tectonics, likely since the Eoarchean, has led to heat loss at plate margins and secular cooling of the mantle, resulting in the decrease of geothermal gradients and the increase of rheological strength at convergent plate margins. Modern plate tectonics is characterized by the predominance of rigid plate margins for cold subduction, and it has prevailed through the Phanerozoic. In contrast, ancient plate tectonics, that prevailed in the Archean and Proterozoic, is dominated by relatively ductile plate margins for collisional thickening at forearc depths and then warm subduction to subarc depths. In either period, the plate divergence after lithospheric breakup must be coupled with the plate convergence in both time and space, otherwise it is impossible for the operation of plate tectonics. In this context, the creation and maintenance of plate divergent-convergent coupling systems are responsible for the onset and operation of plate tectonics, respectively. Although a global network of mobile belts is common between major plates on modern Earth, it is difficult to find its geological record on early Earth if microplates would prevail at that time. In either case, it is important to identify different types of the geological record on Earth in order to discriminate between the different styles of plate tectonics in different periods of geological history.