Plate tectonics and mantle controls on plume dynamics

Abstract

Mantle plumes provide valuable information about whole-mantle convection: they originate at the core-mantle boundary, cross Earth's mantle and interact with the lithosphere. For instance, it has been proposed that the mobility/stability of plumes depends on plume intrinsic properties, on how slabs interact with the basal boundary layer, on mantle flow, or on their proximity to mid-ocean ridges.Here, we use 3D-spherical models of mantle convection generating self-consistent plate-like behaviour to investigate the mechanisms linking tectonics and mantle convection to plume dynamics. Our models produce fully-dynamic mantle plumes that rise vertically with deflection <10° and present excess temperatures, rising speeds, buoyancy and heat fluxes comparable to observations. In the absence of plate tectonics, plumes are stable and their lifetime exceeds hundreds of million years. With plate tectonics, plumes are more mobile, and we identify four physical mechanisms controlling their stability. 1/ Fixed plumes are located at saddle points of basal mantle flow. 2/ Plumes moving at speeds between 0.5-1 cmyr−1 are slowly entrained by passive mantle flow. 3/ Fast plume motions between 2-5 cmyr−1 lasting several tens of million years are caused by slab push. 4/ Plumes occasionally drift at speeds >5 cmyr−1 over <10 Myr through plume merging. We do not observe systematic anchoring of plumes to mid-oceanic ridges. Independent of the presence of a dense basal layer, plate-like regimes decrease the lifetime of plumes compared to stagnant-lid models. Plume age, temperature excess or buoyancy flux are not diagnostic of plume lateral speed. The fraction of plumes moving by less than 0.5 cmyr−1 is >25%, which suggests that fixed hotspot reference frames can be defined from carefully selected hotspot tracks.