Plantation Disaster Capitalism in Maui: Reckoning with Tourism after the Fire

Abstract

Maui residents are reckoning with tourism in the aftermath of the 2023 fires. Drawing from historical sources and popular media reports, we argue that beyond the island’s strained relationship with the tourism industry, residents are contending with the slow emergency of plantation disaster capitalism. We draw from Naomi Klein and Kapua’ala Sproat’s (2023) concept of plantation disaster capitalism which identifies the plantation industry’s domination of resources as the basis of tourism’s untethered control of land and water on the island. These crisis-driven industries perpetuate dependence through ongoing cycles of accumulation by dispossession. The concept of ‘slow emergencies’ further accounts for how, while the Maui fires rapidly destroyed lives, over a century and a half of settler colonial, racial, and capitalist relationships had already restructured landscapes and livelihoods and set the stage for the 2023 disaster. In critically addressing calls for tourism’s resurgence, this conceptual paper contributes to emerging scholarship on plantation disaster capitalism in tourism destinations.