Plant production and nitrogen accumulation above- and belowground in low and tall birch tundra communities: the influence of snow and litter

Abstract

A vegetation transition to taller and denser deciduous shrub tundra is currently occurring in many locations across the low Arctic, and is associated with climate change. Here, we investigated if deeper snow is a mechanism for enhanced shrub growth. To determine if a moderate and climatically realistic increase in snow depth can enhance shrub productivity, we compared growth responses between ambient and experimentally deepened snow plots in low birch hummock tundra. To determine the potential influence of factors other than deepened snow that are associated with taller, denser shrubs, we also compared shrub growth between low birch hummock and tall birch-dominated tundra. Neither deciduous shrub above- nor belowground production nor nitrogen accumulation was enhanced by deepened snow. However, deciduous birch shrub new shoot production was 23× larger and total vascular shoot to belowground biomass ratios were higher in the tall birch tundra than the birch hummock (~0.7 and ~0.4, respectively), indicating that the combination of deeper snow together with other internal feedbacks greatly enhanced birch growth. Together, our results strongly suggest that the much larger litter production in tall birch ecosystems is an important internal feedback that may or may not interact with deeper snow to promote birch growth in tall shrub tundra.