Plant cation-anion balance as affected by the ionic composition of the growing medium

Abstract

Plants that remove an excess of cations over anions may cause soil acidification. The acidification potential of plants has been evaluated using solution culture techniques, but the influence of ionic composition of the medium on the plant cation-anion balance remains unclear. Our objective was to determine how electrolyte concentration and salt type affect the cation- anion balance of two test plants [barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) and kochia (Kochia scoparia L. Schrad.)]. Seedlings were grown in sand culture and irrigated with nutrient solution (Hoagland’s solution), which was adjusted to a range of electrolyte concentrations (target electrical conductivity of 7.5, 17.5 and 27.5 dS m−1) using either chloride or sulphate salts. Increase in electrolyte concentration reduced yield of kochia, a salt-tolerant plant, by up to 38%. Total cation (Ca + Mg + K + Na) equivalents in kochia exceeded those of anions (Cl + S + P + NO3) by 250 to 280 cmolc kg−1 of dry matter. Electrolyte concentration had no effect on the cation-anion balance of kochia, but excess cation values were significantly greater in the sulphate than in the chloride system. Kochia had a large content of water-soluble oxalate (194 to 226 cmolc kg−1), which was linearly related to the excess cation content. Growth of barley was severely restricted at the intermediate and high electrolyte concentrations. Cations exceeded anions by 21 to 59 cmolc kg−1 of barley dry matter. Excess cation content was greater in the sulphate than in the chloride medium, but electrolyte concentration did not have a consistent effect on the cation-anion balance. The small amounts of oxalate found in barley (0.9 to 2.6 cmolc kg−1) were insufficient to balance the cation excess.