Abstract
BackgroundPhytotoxins of various classes and origin are often found in their cationic form in the soil environment and thus, their overall soil behavior may be strongly affected by all geosorbents presenting cation exchange capacity (CEC). In addition to soil organic carbon (SOC), clays may exhibit great potential as sorbents for cationic organic chemicals. Therefore, 52 compounds of the major phytotoxin classes alkaloids, terpenoids and steroids were investigated with regard to their sorption behavior to the clay minerals kaolinite (low CEC) and montmorillonite (high CEC) by means of continuous flow column sorption experiments as a high-throughput alternative to traditional batch sorption experiments.ResultsIn total, sorption coefficients log Dclay [L kg−1] were quantifiable for 26 phytotoxins on kaolinite (log Dclay > 0.1) and 33 on montmorillonite (log Dclay > 0.5). They ranged from 0.14 ± 0.09 for the pyrrolizidine alkaloid senkirkine on kaolinite to 3.05 ± 0.03 for the indole alkaloid brucine on montmorillonite. Although maximum sorbed concentrations lay well below the CEC for both clay minerals, sorption non-linearity was observed in some cases where as little as 0.1% of all cation exchange sites were occupied. Contrary to the expectations, sorption non-linearity could not be wholly explained by saturation of available sorption sites; for protonated tertiary amines with aromatic moieties, cooperative sorption seemingly took place and the results indicated a significant increase in sorption affinities within a very limited concentration range. Comparing montmorillonite and SOC, notable differences in preferences of cationic sorbates were observed between phytotoxins with and without aromatic moieties (e.g., isoquinoline versus pyrrolizidine alkaloids) as well as between N-heterocycles and N-heteroaromatics in particular (e.g., strychnine versus gramine; both indole alkaloids).ConclusionsOverall, clay sorption seems a result of the interplay of charge location on the sorbent and various structural features of the sorbates. To confirm observed tendencies towards cooperative sorption for certain cationic phytotoxins, further studies with higher concentrations are needed. Nevertheless, obtained sorption coefficients indicate that a high proportion of phytotoxin sorption in soils may be attributed to clay minerals. Thus, clay minerals possess the ability to decrease total cationic phytotoxin environmental mobility.
Highlights
Phytotoxins of various classes and origin are often found in their cationic form in the soil environment and their overall soil behavior may be strongly affected by all geosorbents presenting cation exchange capacity (CEC)
Average values of experimentally derived sorption coefficients for the phytotoxins investigated in this study are given in Table 2 for both kaolinite and montmorillonite
Neutral sorbates were poorly retained by any sorbent and rarely exceeded the quantification thresholds with retention being limited to the neutral alkaloids, colchicine (COL) and caffeine (CAF), as well as the steroid oleandrin (OLE) on montmorillonite and the steroid cinobufagin (CIN) on kaolinite
Summary
Phytotoxins of various classes and origin are often found in their cationic form in the soil environment and their overall soil behavior may be strongly affected by all geosorbents presenting cation exchange capacity (CEC). As demonstrated in a preceding study, sorption of the majority of investigated alkaloids to soil organic carbon (SOC) is dominated by cation exchange processes on negatively charged functional groups [12] Electrostatic interactions such as cation exchange and sorption to geosorbents other than SOC are rarely integrated in soil sorption models commonly used in environmental exposure assessment. Sorption of the indole alkaloid strychnine (STY, base pKa = 8.37) was previously observed to directly correlate with soil clay content rather than with SOC content [15] In combination, these results highlight the fact that the role of clay minerals in determining the phase distribution of protonated phytotoxins and their mobility in soil may be substantially undervalued
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary Sign-in/Register to access full text options 
Free) 
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a call
