Physical structure of constitutional isomers influences antiproliferation activity of thiosemicarbazone-alkylthiocarbamate copper complexes

Abstract

A series of hybrid thiosemicarbazone-alkylthiocarbamate copper complexes with similar electronic environments but distinct physical structures have been prepared, characterized, and evaluated for antiproliferation activity. The complexes include the constitutional isomers (1-phenylpropane-1-imine-(O-ethylthiocarbamato)-2-one-(N-methylthiosemicarbazonato))copper(II) (CuL1) and (1-phenylpropane-1-one-(N-methylthiosemicarbazonato)-2-imine-(O-ethylthiocarbamato))copper(II) (CuL2) along with (1-propane-1-imine-(O-ethylthiocarbamato)-2-one-(N-methylthiosemicarbazonato))copper(II) (CuL3). Complexes CuL1 and CuL2 differ in the positions of the pendent thiosemicarbazone (TSC) and alkylthiocarbamate (ATC) moieties on the 1-phenylpropane backbone. Complex CuL3 employs a propane backbone with the TSC in the 2-position as in CuL1. The isomer pair CuL1 and CuL2 have equivalent electronic environments with indistinguishable CuII/I potentials (E1/2 = -0.86 V vs. ferrocenium/ferrocene) and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra (g∥ = 2.26, g⊥ = 2.08). The electronic structure of CuL3 has a similar E1/2 of -0.84 V and identical EPR parameters to CuL1, 2. Single crystal X-ray diffraction studies confirm a consistent donor environment with no substantial variation in the CuN or CuS bond distances and angles between the complexes. The antiproliferation activities of the CuL1–3 were evaluated against the lung adenocarcinoma cell line (A549) and nonmalignant lung fibroblast cell line (IMR-90) using the MTT assay. CuL1 had the highest A549 activity (A549EC50 = 0.065 μM) and selectivity (IMR-90EC50/A549EC50 = 20). The constitutional isomer CuL2 displayed decreased A549 activity (0.18 μM) and selectivity (10.6). The complex CuL3 displayed activity (0.009 μM) similar to CuL1 but with a lack of selectivity (1.0). Cellular copper loading determined by ICP-MS was consistent with the activity and selectivity trends. The complexes CuL1–3 did not induce reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation.