Photobiology of melanin pigmentation: Dose/response of skin to sunlight and its contents

Abstract

A randomized double-blind clinical trial involving twenty-two volunteers was conducted in two locations (Orlando, FL, and St. Paul, MN) to test the efficacy of the newly designed ultraviolet monitor badges (Sun Timers), described in another paper by us in this issue of the Journal, 1 and to establish the relationship between spectral band exposure dose and the biologic responses of erythema and pigmentation. Individuals with skin types II, III, and IV, exhibiting differences in reactivity to solar radiation, were exposed to varying doses of full-spectrum sunlight through templates mounted on the lower portion of the back. Simultaneously, on the upper portion of the back, the same volunteers were exposed through two different types of polyester filters that transmitted ultraviolet A (UVA) and visible radiation. Using templates with windows, exposures to full-spectrum sunlight, UVA, and visible radiation were carried out to 1, 2, 3, 6, and 9 sunburn units (approximately 30–270 millijoules/cm 2 between 10:30 a.m. and 3:30 p.m. daylight time in mid summer), measured with the aid of a Robertson-Berger meter and an IL700 International Light radiometer. Erythema and pigmentation resulting from these exposures were graded (double-blind) immediately after exposure, at 24 hours, and after 5 days. Numerical skin response ratings at each exposure dose for different spectral bands were then averaged and plotted. It was found that the UVB monitor response was predictive of a 24-hour erythema response and 5-day pigmentation response within 30% of the biologic average for skin types II, III, and IV. UVA radiation stimulated melanogenesis. The minimal melanogenic dose (MMD) for skin type II was the same as the minimal erythemogenic dose (MED). The MMD for individuals of skin types III and IV was distinctly less than their MED. Thus, melanogenesis can be stimulated with a suberythemal dose of UVB or UVA radiation. The sun protection factor values of melanin for melanized skin have been estimated to vary from 1.0 (skin type II) to 4.3 (skin types V and VI).