Abstract

Despite its widely demonstrated usefulness, there is still room for improvement in the basic Permutation Entropy (PE) algorithm, as several subsequent studies have proposed in the recent years. For example, some improved PE variants try to address possible PE weaknesses, such as its only focus on ordinal information, and not on amplitude, or the possible detrimental impact of equal values in subsequences due to motif ambiguity. Other evolved PE methods try to reduce the influence of input parameters. A good representative of this last point is the Bubble Entropy (BE) method. BE is based on sorting relations instead of ordinal patterns, and its promising capabilities have not been extensively assessed yet. The objective of the present study was to comparatively assess the classification performance of this new method, and study and exploit the possible synergies between PE and BE. The claimed superior performance of BE over PE was first evaluated by conducting a series of time series classification tests over a varied and diverse experimental set. The results of this assessment apparently suggested that there is a complementary relationship between PE and BE, instead of a superior/inferior relationship. A second set of experiments using PE and BE simultaneously as the input features of a clustering algorithm, demonstrated that with a proper algorithm configuration, classification accuracy and robustness can benefit from both measures.

Highlights

  • Regardless of its relatively young age in comparison with other entropy statistics, Permutation Entropy (PE) has soon become one of the most utilised time series entropy–related measures

  • These experiments included a variation of the parameter m, from 3 to 8, since input parameter influence is another topic of intense debate and research in the scientific literature

  • The clustering method achieves a lower performance than the methods individually, but with a small difference for m < 6

Read more

Summary

Introduction

Regardless of its relatively young age in comparison with other entropy statistics, Permutation Entropy (PE) has soon become one of the most utilised time series entropy–related measures. It was proposed in the well known paper by Bandt and Pompe [1] in 2002, and since it has given rise to a number of applications and further algorithm developments. This number is growing exponentially [2], as a clear evidence of the utility of the PE approach. More frequent applications are based on electroencephalogram [5, 6, 7, 8] and heart rate variability [9, 10, 11] analysis

Objectives
Methods
Results
Discussion
Conclusion
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call