Performance of acid- and base-modified biochars for the removal of antibiotics from water under dynamic conditions

Abstract

The increased recycling of treated municipal wastewater (TMW) to agricultural land is potentially hampered by the presence of antibiotic compounds, which may lead to the spread of antibiotic resistance. Biochar-based adsorption has been widely assessed as a means of polishing TMW to remove antibiotics prior to use; however, relatively little is known about how acid and base modification of biochar impacts its antibiotic retention capabilities, especially under the dynamic (flow-through) conditions inherent in proposed polishing systems. Using small columns of sand mixed with dairy manure or rice husk biochars (initial pH = 8.48 and 8.91, respectively) modified with acid or base, the retention of trimethoprim (TMP), sulfamethoxazole (SMZ), and sulfapyridine (SPD) was assessed. For SMZ and SPD, retention by the columns was consistently markedly lower than that measured in batch studies, indicating that equilibrium data may overestimate the retention of more realistic (dynamic) systems. TMP was completely retained by all biochars under both conditions. In columns, SMZ retention was strongly controlled by its pH-dependent speciation (greater retention at low pH, i.e., in acid modified biochars). SPD retention was strongly controlled by biochar surface area, which was markedly increased in the acid-modified dairy manure biochar and base-modified rice husk biochar. The findings indicate that acid or base modification of certain biochars may improve retention of sulfonamide antibiotics (which are known to be particularly difficult to remove from TMW) even under dynamic conditions. Biochar-based polishing systems comprising such biochars may offer potential in mitigating the spread of antibiotics, and hence antibiotic resistance, in agricultural settings.