Performance of a spring‐feeding moth in relation to time of oviposition and bud‐burst phenology of different host species

Abstract

Abstract. 1. As a spring‐feeding moth committed to immature foliage, the autumnal moth Epirrita autumnata (Lepidoptera, Geometridae) must have egg hatch synchronised with the bud‐burst of its host plants. Due to large individual variation in the length of the pupal period, however, E. autumnata populations exhibit a prolonged period of flight and oviposition. Because the timing of oviposition in autumn is associated with the timing of egg hatch in the following spring, the time window for egg hatch expands and more potential hosts may become attainable. This suggestion was evaluated under field conditions by rearing E. autumnata eggs and larvae on four different hosts.2. The performance of E. autumnata was measured by using estimates for fecundity (pupal mass) as well as survivorship of eggs and larvae. Based on the availability of foliage and phenological synchrony between larval and leaf development, early‐laid eggs and the larvae originating from them were predicted to perform better on the hosts that have early‐flushing leaves. On the late‐flushing hosts, the larvae that hatched later were predicted to perform better than the larvae that hatched earlier. Half of the trials were exposed to predators and parasitoids, while the rest were conducted inside mesh‐bags preventing larval dispersal and mortality due to natural enemies.3. The results of the experiment did not support the simple predictions. In particular, host‐plant quality and natural enemies appeared to operate discordantly between early‐ and late‐laid eggs. Larvae from the late‐laid eggs had rapid development during the larval stages and pupated at the same time and with the same pupal mass as the larvae hatched from the early‐laid eggs.4. The results indicate an occurrence of several, unknown selective forces in E. autumnata populations maintaining variation in the length of the pupal period, timing of oviposition, and timing of egg hatch.