Perceptuomotor compatibility effects in vowels: Beyond phonemic identity

Payam Ghaffarvand Mokari,Daniel Williams,Adamantios Gafos

doi:10.3758/s13414-020-02014-1

Payam Ghaffarvand Mokari, Daniel Williams + Show 1 more

Open Access

https://doi.org/10.3758/s13414-020-02014-1

Copy DOI

Abstract

Perceptuomotor compatibility between phonemically identical spoken and perceived syllables has been found to speed up response times (RTs) in speech production tasks. However, research on compatibility effects between perceived and produced stimuli at the subphonemic level is limited. Using a cue–distractor task, we investigated the effects of phonemic and subphonemic congruency in pairs of vowels. On each trial, a visual cue prompted individuals to produce a response vowel, and after the visual cue appeared a distractor vowel was auditorily presented while speakers were planning to produce the response vowel. The results revealed effects on RTs due to phonemic congruency (same vs. different vowels) between the response and distractor vowels, which resemble effects previously seen for consonants. Beyond phonemic congruency, we assessed how RTs are modulated as a function of the degree of subphonemic similarity between the response and distractor vowels. Higher similarity between the response and distractor in terms of phonological distance—defined by number of mismatching phonological features—resulted in faster RTs. However, the exact patterns of RTs varied across response–distractor vowel pairs. We discuss how different assumptions about phonological feature representations may account for the different patterns observed in RTs across response–distractor pairs. Our findings on the effects of perceived stimuli on produced speech at a more detailed level of representation than phonemic identity necessitate a more direct and specific formulation of the perception–production link. Additionally, these results extend previously reported perceptuomotor interactions mainly involving consonants to vowels.

Highlights

Perceptuomotor compatibility between phonemically identical spoken and perceived syllables has been found to speed up response times (RTs) in speech production tasks
In exploring how the speech production and perception systems interact during online processing, an experimental paradigm that requires concurrent use of both systems has been revealing
We addressed how the speech production and perception systems interact during online processing of vowels by using an experimental task which requires concurrent use of both systems

Summary

Introduction

Perceptuomotor compatibility between phonemically identical spoken and perceived syllables has been found to speed up response times (RTs) in speech production tasks. Our findings on the effects of perceived stimuli on produced speech at a more detailed level of representation than phonemic identity necessitate a more direct and specific formulation of the perception–production link These results extend previously reported perceptuomotor interactions mainly involving consonants to vowels. Reaction times for the required responses were faster if the symbol cued the response consistent with the video In interpreting this result, Kerzel and Bekkering (2000) proposed that seeing a visual gesture activates the motor codes to produce that gesture. Instead, the motor codes activated from the visual stimulus are not congruent with the required response (e.g., seeing a video of a face producing /d/-initial syllable while cued to respond by saying /ba/), the incompatible response is activated, but must be inhibited, leading to slower reaction times

Objectives

Results

Conclusion