Peering Into the Future: A First Look at the CBME Transition to Practice Stage in Diagnostic Radiology

Abstract

Queen's University (Kingston, ON, Canada) adopted a competency-based medical education (CBME) curriculum for Diagnostic Radiology residency training in an accelerated manner in 2017, with the curriculum comprised of four stages of training. This article focuses on the final stage (Transition to Practice), during which assessment methods of the new national curriculum (implemented in July 2022) were piloted. This study aims to highlight the challenges and opportunities associated with the implementation of CBME in Diagnostic Radiology training and specific considerations for programs undergoing this curricular transition. Ethics approval was provided by the affiliated hospital Research Ethics Board. All relevant electronic assessments pertaining to all trainees who had completed the Transition to Practice stage (n=3) were collated, deidentified, analyzed, and presented in tabulated format. A total of 39 evaluations completed by 13 assessors were assessed, with an average time of 3minutes and 6seconds to complete an assessment form. Also, 95% of evaluations were rated as entrustments. However, no residents met the minimum number of required entrustments for all five stage-specific Entrustable Professional Activities. These 39 evaluations included 219 milestone rating scores, with 86% rated as "achieved." Following review by the residency program Competence Committee, all three residents were promoted from the Transition to Practice stage. Challenges in CBME implementation include the number and quality of resident assessments. Strategies for success may include providing clear guidelines and training for both faculty and residents, early identification and intervention, and adopting a holistic evaluation strategy. CBME has the potential to enhance medical education quality by emphasizing learner progress toward competency and providing personalized feedback and support.