Pedogenic pathways and deep weathering controls on soil organic carbon in Pacific Northwest forest soils

Abstract

Characterizing the distribution and dynamics of organic carbon in soil is critical for quantifying changes in the global carbon cycle. In particular, weathering controls on near-surface and deep (>1 m) soil organic carbon (SOC) dynamics have been proposed but limited data prevents us from predicting SOC over topographically complex landscapes and quantifying how changes in climate and perturbations, such as wildfire or land management, influence SOC stocks. To advance our understanding of how weathering alters soil geochemistry and influences SOC storage, we synthesize previous data with a new analysis of the Siuslaw River soil chronosequence from terraces in the Oregon Coast Range, a region that harbors the richest SOC inventories in the continental US. We analyze how the relationships between soil geochemistry, physical properties, and SOC storage vary with weathering status and pathways across soils that span 0.041 to 990 kyr and vary in depth from 1 m to >10 m. To distinguish the key properties and processes influencing SOC storage at different depths, we break our analysis into three depth intervals: 0–30, 30–100, and >100 cm. Our results suggest that the processes that control SOC stocks vary systematically with time and depth owing to weathering impacts on soil properties and pedogenic development. At 30 kyr we observe a peak in SOC stock in the top 100 cm coincident with a peak in oxalate extractable Al and Fe concentrations, representing secondary poorly crystalline minerals, which is consistent with previous studies. We also observe a decline in shallow SOC stock for >30 kyr soils as poorly crystalline minerals are replaced by more stable crystalline forms and soils become clay dominated. At 120 kyr, SOC below 100 cm starts to contribute significantly to the total SOC profile inventory and by 990 kyr, this fraction composes >40% of the total SOC stock. Taken together, our results indicate that total SOC stock increases with soil age as the increased intensity of bedrock weathering deepens the critical zone, creating accommodation space for deep SOC storage. These findings reveal the intimate link between poorly crystalline minerals and SOC and suggest that systematic analysis of soil development in the critical zone provides a first-order constraint on SOC stocks.