Patients’ Perceptions of Importance for Self-Administered Correct Site Surgery Checklist: A Multisite Study

Abstract

PurposeThe purpose of this study was to describe and validate the association between patient's self-administered correct site checklist and perceptions of importance for safe surgery. DesignA multisite nonexperimental, quantitative, descriptive study. MethodsA convenience sample of 173 adult patients from four different geographical multisite hospitals was included in the study. Inclusion criteria were age 18 to 75 years old, scheduled for surgery/procedure with laterality and ability to follow instructions. After IRB approval, investigators explained the purpose of the study, process and obtained consent from willing participants. Participants with clinical or behavioral limitations were excluded from the study. Participants completed a 24 item survey before and during surgery using a four-point Likert scale from one (not important) to four (extremely important). Descriptive data was analyzed using means, standard deviations, and percentage. All data was summarized and analyzed with STATA 12. FindingsMost of the participants perceived the importance of the survey checklist items positively implying that the active engagement is an important role for safe surgery. However, a few participants reported some of the items as not important/somewhat important: “It is on my left or right side” (6.9%); “surgery on my: (state your limb) and (right or left site) (1.9-3%); “check electronic access or copy of imaging with correct name and site” (14.9%); “state your name and birthday” (4%), “check correct ID bracelet information” (2.9%) and “believe in having an active role in preventing error” (2.3%). Some participants responded, “My surgeon knows it or surgery has been scheduled”. Findings indicated that even though the importance of correct site surgery is critical for patient's surgery, a few patients reported it as noncritical and relied on healthcare team for their safety. ConclusionsThis study validated the importance of the patients’ perceived roles in promoting safe, correct site surgery and by engaging patients in mitigating correct site surgical errors. Therefore, inclusion of patients as an integral part of the healthcare team is necessary through education and encouragement to speak out.