Paths of Influence: The Direct and Indirect Determinants of Marine Managed Area Success

Abstract

An analysis of the factors associated with the outcomes of marine managed areas (MMAs) located near two distinct types of communities—those whose economies are highly dependent on fishing, and those whose economies are more diverse—is presented. A path analytic approach is used to investigate both direct and indirect effects of selected independent variables on MMA project outcomes. Results indicate that enforcement should not be excessively noticeable or heavy handed, particularly in communities that rely on fishing for their livelihoods; engaging in capacity-building activities in communities where they are not needed not only wastes management resources but may in fact have a negative effect on project outcomes; and improved accountability in the management of the MMA is probably more important than other more costly activities.