Paternity pseudo-exclusion caused by tetragametic chimerism in a gestational surrogacy case

Abstract

Chimerism is a condition when an organism is composed of two or more populations of genetically distinct cells. Chimerism often produces curious results of medical and genetic investigations and could be a major cause of false negative conclusions in parentage testing. Here we describe a paternity pseudo-exclusion due to tetragametic chimerism in a gestational surrogacy case originated in a fertility clinic. Initial analysis using a buccal swab from the child and a peripheral blood sample from the father showed paternity exclusion at 6 STR loci. To find out the reason for observed paternal discrepancy father's semen sample used for IVF and samples from other tissues were genotyped. Buccal swabs, semen, hair follicles, nail clippings and cerumen showed identical mixed autosomal STR profiles originated from two genetically different cell lines and for all the 24 informative loci contain paternal obligate alleles. Results of Y-STR profiling of all paternal sample types showed a DNA profile originated from a single man. The mixed profiles obtained for different tissue types suggest that two genetically different cell lines contributed to formation of both the endoderm and the ectoderm of the father. The mesoderm seems to be monoclonal having originated from a genetically homogenous cell line as evidenced by the STR profile of peripheral blood. Such allelic pattern for various tissues suggests that the clonal origin happened at the very early stage of embryonic development. Approaches to minimise the rate of false exclusions in DNA parentage tests due to chimerism are discussed.