Paternal leakage inheritance and a fitness cost are associated with the chloroplastic psbA gene controlled metribuzin tolerance in lentil (Lens culinaris)

Abstract

Reciprocal F1, F2 and F3 populations of lentil (Lens culinaris Medik.) were developed by crossing between lines, with a chloroplastic psbA gene mutation conferring tolerance to the photosystem II inhibitor herbicide metribuzin, and sensitive parent PBA Flash, to understand the genetic control of the herbicide tolerance. Additionally, reciprocal BC1F2 populations were developed to identify any fitness penalty associated with the metribuzin tolerance. Phenotyping and genotyping results of the F1, F2, and F3 populations identified a predominantly maternal inheritance pattern, but with a level of paternal leakage. Paternal leakage occurred in approximately 20% of F1 phenotypes, when including lines showing heteroplasmy (the existence of maternal and paternal chloroplasts within an individual). Field experiments with BC1F2 and BC1F3 lines confirmed this biparental inheritance pattern. Grain yield was reduced by 20–40% in metribuzin tolerant backcrossed lines compared with sensitive lines. Net assimilation rate at the onset of anthesis and plant dry weight at mid anthesis and maturity were also reduced in the tolerant lines suggesting reduced photosynthetic efficiency associated with the metribuzin tolerance results in lower dry weight and grain yield in the tolerant lines. The mode of inheritance and associated yield penalty of the tolerance trait will complicate its introgression in lentil breeding programs. However, the high level of tolerance and unique weed control benefits of this trait suggest that this form of metribuzin tolerance in lentil, which is similar to triazine tolerant canola (Brassica napus L.), could be adopted.