Oxygen isotope study of the Asuka-881020 CH chondrite II: Porphyritic chondrules

Abstract

Oxygen isotope ratios and elemental compositions of porphyritic chondrules and olivine and pyroxene fragments in the Asuka-881020 CH chondrite were analyzed. The oxygen isotope ratios inside individual porphyritic chondrules are homogeneous within the uncertainty, except for relict grains of olivine and low-Ca pyroxene that have distinct oxygen isotope ratios. The average oxygen isotope ratios of the individual chondrules plot along and above the primitive chondrule mineral (PCM) line with Δ17O (=δ17O – 0.52 × δ18O) values from −4.7 ‰ to +4.1 ‰. The olivine and pyroxene fragments, which have Δ17O values ranging from −2.1 ‰ to +3.2 ‰, are likely to be fragments of the porphyritic chondrules.Unlike the non-porphyritic chondrules in CH and CB chondrites and chondrules in other carbonaceous chondrites, the type I and II chondrules do not show a systematic difference in the Δ17O values. Furthermore, the Δ17O values of the type I chondrules increase from −4.7 ‰ to +4.1 ‰ with increasing Mg# (=molar [MgO]/[MgO + FeO] × 100) from 96 to 99. We argue that the positive Δ17O-Mg# trend is explained by an addition of 16O-poor carbon-rich organics as a reducing agent to the relatively 16O-rich precursor silicate, which is a new environment for chondrule formation. This hypothesis is supported by the two lines of evidence observed in the present study. (1) The chondrules and fragments with higher Δ17O values show larger deviations from the PCM line towards low δ18O, suggesting oxygen isotope mass fractionation between the chondrule melt and CO or CO2. (2) Olivine phenocrysts in the chondrules with high Δ17O values contain Ni-poor Fe-metal particles surrounded by silica-rich glass, which may be reduction products during the chondrule formation. Thus, it is suggested that the porphyritic chondrules in CH and CB chondrites have different origins from chondrules in any other chondrite types, even from the non-porphyritic chondrules in CH and CB chondrites.