Oxidative stress effects are not correlated with differences in heat tolerance among congeners of Mytilus.

Abstract

The physiological mechanisms that limit thermal tolerance are broadly relevant to comparative biology and global change. Species differences in macromolecular stability play important roles in evolved patterns of heat tolerance, but other mechanisms such as oxidative stress have also been hypothesized to contribute. For example, mussels in the genus Mytilus exhibit evolved physiological differences at several levels of organization that have been linked with interspecific differences in whole-organism heat tolerance. Both omics and behavioral studies suggested that variation in resistance to oxidative stress plays a role in these differences. Functional data are needed to test this hypothesis. Here, we compared three Mytilus congeners to examine whether susceptibility to oxidative stress contributes to acute heat tolerance. We assayed the activity of two antioxidant enzymes (catalase, superoxide dismutase), as well as levels of oxidative damage to lipids, DNA and individual proteins (using gel-based proteomics methods). In addition, we assessed these oxidative stress responses after repeated episodes of heat stress experienced in air or while immersed in seawater, given that survival and competitive outcomes between Mytilus congeners differ in these two contexts. The results are generally inconsistent with patterns that would be expected if oxidative stress contributes to thermal sensitivity. Rather, the more heat-tolerant congeners suffer comparable or even elevated levels of oxidative damage. As predicted, different treatment contexts led to distinct changes in proteome-wide abundance patterns and, to a lesser extent, protein carbonylation profiles. Overall, the results question the relevance of oxidative damage as a mediator of heat tolerance in this genus.