Oxidative damage in relation to a female plumage badge: evidence for signalling costs

Abstract

Badges of status may be controlled by costs derived from increased aggression from dominant individuals. This cost could be translated into elevated metabolic levels and a concomitant disruption of oxidative balance. Some females in Iberian pied flycatcher Ficedula hypoleuca populations exhibit a white forehead patch similar to that exhibited by all males in this species, functioning in aggressive interactions between females when competing for breeding sites. To test if social stress imposes costs on signalling, we painted white patches on females without natural patches (NP) and compared them with females with natural control (NU). We also over-painted the natural patch in other females (FP) and compared to females with control natural patches (FU). We obtained for the whole sample of females data on reproductive investment, morphology and oxidative damage measured by blood malondialdehydes (MDA), and in a subsample of females variables related to parental care during incubation and the early nestling stage. FP and FU did not differ significantly in any variable which negates an effect of paint itself. However, NP females showed significant higher levels of MDA than NU females when controlling for breeding success for the whole sample, and for female incubation attendance for the parental care subsample. When including the four treatments, there was a significant interaction between the paint treatment and the presence/absence of badges before the experiment when controlling for the significant negative effect of incubation attendance on MDA. Addition of a badge to females without one leads to increased oxidative damage possibly mediated by social control. Badges of status in female pied flycatchers may operate as badges of oxidative status.