Overpressured layer chromatography in comparison with thin-layer and high-performance liquid chromatography for the determination of coumarins with reference to the composition of the mobile phase

Abstract

The retention behaviour of fifteen closely related coumarins in normal-phase overpressured layer chromatography (OPLC) was studied with the aim of comparing the retentions with those in normal-phase thin-layer chromatography (TLC) and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) when optimization of the mobile phase was carried out according to the PRISMA system. The mobile phase optimization was carried out on TLC plates in unsaturated chambers. The resulting mobile phases were transposed to off-line, non-equilibrated OPLC and further to HPLC. The retention in TLC was measured at 37 selectivity points and in OPLC and HPLC at 13 points. Capacity factors ( k′) and separation factors (α) were calculated in order to study the retention behaviour in the different systems. Two- and three-dimensional evaluations of k′ against selectivity points showed similar retention behaviours for the coumarins in TLC, OPLC and HPLC. The α values for TLC, OPLC and HPLC showed similar patterns in the three-dimensional evaluations. The retention behaviour at different solvent strengths was also examined. According to quadratic regression, k′ showed a dependence on the change in solvent strength. OPLC, which can be considered as a “planar column” technique, and TLC are closely related methods, whereas HPLC shows a different behaviour in the elution process with regard to solvent strength.