Overall Survival and Post-Progression Survival in Advanced Breast Cancer: A Review of Recent Randomized Clinical Trials

Abstract

With the availability of several lines of therapy, overall survival (OS) has been progressively substituted by progression-free survival (PFS) and other tumor-based assessments as the primary efficacy end point in advanced breast cancer trials. We investigated the frequency and determinants of OS gain in the recent literature and the duration of post-progression survival (PPS) according to treatment type and line. We used PubMed to search for phase III trials on systemic antineoplastic therapies published between January 1998 and December 2007 in 11 leading journals. The primary end point was the one stated explicitly, used for N calculation, or listed first. Significant gain was considered as reported P < .05 for superiority trials or proven non-inferiority or equivalence otherwise. We retrieved 76 trials, and gain in OS was reported in 15 cases (19.7%). The median gain in OS was 4.7 months, and such gain was more frequent when there was significant gain in PFS and in second-line and third-line trials. The average median OS was 20.7 months in trials assessing first-line chemotherapy and 31.1 months with first-line hormone therapy. The median proportion of OS accounted for by PPS was significantly longer in hormone therapy trials than in chemotherapy trials, but varied little across treatment lines. A statistically significant gain in OS has been reported in about one in five recent phase III trials in advanced breast cancer, despite the fact that OS has seldom been used as the primary end point. PPS represents nearly two thirds of patient survival after on-trial disease progression.