Outcome of live related and live unrelated renal transplants

Abstract

Summary: This study compares the outcomes of 229 renal transplants, of which 156 were live related renal transplants done at our centre and 73 unrelated transplants done at other centres but followed up at our centre. All the patients were on triple immunosuppression for periods varying between 9 months and 1 year. Patient characteristics, rejections, infections and 1 and 5 years patient and graft survival were analyzed in the two groups. the outcome of patients who continued on cyclosporine beyond 1 year was compared to those who discontinued cyclosporine at 1 year. Males predominated (191 vs 38) in both groups, while younger patients (<50 years) predominated in live related group (152 vs four). There was no difference in the incidence of infection, rejection, graft dysfunction, graft loss or death between the two groups. the 1 and 5 year patient survival in the related and unrelated group, (93.7% and 71.4%vs and 85% and 66%) and graft survival (90.4% and 69.4%vs 83.3% and 65.4%) were similar. However, in the unrelated group, patients who discontinued cyclosporine had a higher incidence of rejections (38%vs 14%) and graft loss (43%vs 11.8%), while in the related group no such difference was found. It is concluded that 1 and 5 year patient and graft survival is comparable between live related and live unrelated transplantation. However, in the unrelated group it is necessary to continue cyclosporine beyond 1 year in order to achieve comparable results.