Outcome after salvage radiotherapy (brachytherapy +/− external) in patients with a vaginal recurrence from endometrial carcinomas

Abstract

Background and purpose: The vagina is the site most commonly affected by loco-regional failure in endometrial carcinoma (EC). The aim of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of vaginal brachytherapy (BT) combined or not with whole pelvic external radiotherapy (RT) for the treatment of patients with vaginal recurrences from endometrial cancer. Patients and methods: Between 1986 and 1999 25 women were treated at the Institut Gustave Roussy (IGR) for a vaginal relapse (VR) from EC. Patient characteristics were as follows: median age 65 years (range 43–84), histologic type: adenocarcinoma (21 patients); endometrioid carcinoma (three patients); adenoacanthoma (one patient); FIGO staging for initial disease: Ia, three; Ib, eight; Ic, four; II, seven; IIIa, two; IVa, one. The initial tumor was treated by surgery alone in 18 patients, or surgery combined with RT and/or BT in seven patients. A VR occurred in a median interval of 21 months (range 2–89); 10/25 (40%) occurred within the first year following initial treatment. The recurrence was exclusively in the vagina in 18 patients and was associated with parametrial and or nodal involvement in seven patients; it was localized in the upper 1/3 of the vagina in nine patients, in the upper 2/3 or the entire vagina in 11 patients or in the lower 1/3 in five patients. The largest tumor diameter ranged from 10 to 70 mm (median: 25 mm). The treatment of the VR included low-dose rate endocavitary BT in all cases: three patients received endocavitary BT alone, or it was associated with external RT in 22 patients or delivered after surgical removal of the lesion in nine patients. Seven patients were submitted to further irradiation combining endocavitary and interstitial BT. Results: Local control was achieved in 23 patients (92%). With a follow-up ranging from 4 to 154 months, 13 patients have died (ten due to metastasis, two of intercurrent disease and two due to local tumor progression) and ten patients are alive and disease free. The 3-year actuarial survival was 48%. Late radiation-related sequelae were observed in nine patients (mucous necrosis in one patient, moderate sclerosis in six patients) in an interval varying between 8 and 45 months. The majority of recurrences occurred in patients who had not previously received irradiation, which emphasizes the role of systematic prophylatic post-operative vaginal BT. Extra-vaginal extension ( P<0.001), the tumor size ( P<0.03) and the stage of initial disease ( P<0.01) appeared to have a significant impact on the prognosis. Conclusion: BT combined with external RT is an efficient treatment for VR from EC even in previously irradiated patients. Poor survival remains related to metastatic dissemination.