‘Our Students’ Versus ‘My Students’? Experiences of Subject Teaching by Maltese Primary Church School Teachers

Abstract

Focusing on Year 5 and Year 6, this qualitative study encompasses a sample of six teachers who have employed the subject teaching approach in recent scholastic years in church schools in Malta. This study addresses these teachers’ experiences with the subject teaching approach, while also exploring associated benefits and challenges. The research delves into the perceptions of the teachers and the implications of subject teaching, offering valuable insights into the pedagogical landscape. The study exposes the phenomenon of learning compartmentalization and highlights the possible negative impacts and beneficial outcomes resulting from this pedagogical approach. These are presented in a comprehensive table which not only encompasses the perspective of teachers but also identifies perceived benefits and challenges for learners. While acknowledging the significance of subject teaching at the primary level, the authors recognize the necessity of future research to assess the subject teaching’s comprehensive impact, particularly the psychological support teachers offer within the broader context of holistic education. This paper stands as a catalyst for informed deliberations on the viability of subject teaching, both in Malta and internationally. It may also contribute to potential policy formulation while igniting further investigations in similar domains.