Ornithine Carbamoyltransferase Deficiency in an Adult Male Patient: Significance of Hepatic Ultrastructure in Clinical Diagnosis

Abstract

Ornithine carbamoyltransferase (OCT) activity was deficient (8% of control) in the liver of a 21-year-old man who died after suddenly becoming comatose. Activities of other enzymes of the urea cycle in the liver were normal. There was no known prior illness or injury; the patient, however, had been taking liquid protein supplements to his diet. Hyperammonemia and orotic aciduria were present, and the concentration of lysine in the plasma was elevated. Survey of earlier reports indicates that neither the specific deficiency of hepatic OCT nor the urine and plasma findings provide a basis for definitive diagnosis of the patient's illness as primary OCT deficiency or as Reye's syndrome. Indeed, the age of the patient at onset of symptoms and the absence of any prodromal infection argue against the OCT deficiency being either primary or a sequel to Reye's syndrome. We suggest that it was secondary to mitochondrial injury caused by an unknown agent. Electron microscopic study of hepatocyte ultrastructure lends support to this view; abnormalities of the patient's mitochondria (bizarre, elongated shapes) do not resemble those seen in Reye's syndrome, nor have abnormalities been found in primary OCT deficiency.