Ornament and body size variation and their measurement in natural populations

Abstract

Measurement of intrapopulation variation in secondary sexual traits is a priority in the testing of sexual selection models. However, it is important to take care in the choice of materials and delimitation of populations. The use of museum skins to study variation in male tail ornaments may substantially underrepresent the real degree of intrapopulation variation. Data from live animals in specific areas provide more realistic estimates, and should be used whenever possible. I use as an example field data on male ornament length and body size in Vidua macroura (Aves: Ploceidae), a promiscuous, parasitic African finch with elongated tail plumes. Individual males differ in the timing and rate of ornament growth, and females are therefore faced with a large degree of phenotypic variation in male ornament size, even though genetic variation may not be great. By correcting for seasonal variation in the ornament lengths of males caught at different times, I show that mid-season coefficients of variation in ornament length of breeding males in two populations are as high as 18% and 55%. By contrast, tarsus, wing and unornamented tail lengths of the same males vary from 2 to 4%.