Optimizing Kernel Density Estimation Bandwidth for Road Traffic Accident Hazard Identification: A Case Study of the City of London

Abstract

Road traffic accidents pose significant challenges to sustainable urban safety and intelligent transportation management. The effective hazard identification of crash hotspots is crucial in implementing targeted safety measures. A severity-weighted system was adopted to quantify crash hazard levels. Using 1059 valid crash records of the City of London, the spatial correlations of crash points were first examined via average nearest neighbor analysis. Then, the optimal KDE bandwidth was determined via ArcGIS’s automatic extraction method, multi-distance spatial cluster analysis, and incremental spatial autocorrelation (ISA) analysis. The predictive accuracy index (PAI) was used to evaluate the accuracy of KDE results at various bandwidths. The results revealed a clustered spatial distribution of crash points. The optimized KDE bandwidth obtained via ISA analysis was 134 m, and the yielded PAI was 4.381, indicating better predictive accuracies and balanced hotspot distributions and reflecting both local concentrations and the overall continuity of crash hazard hotspots. Applying this bandwidth to the validation data allowed the successful identification of most high-risk areas and potential crash hazard hotspots attributed to traffic environmental factors; this method exhibits reliability, accuracy, and robustness over medium to long time scales. This workflow can serve as an analytical template for assisting planners in improving the identification accuracy of hazard hotspots, thereby reducing crash occurrences, actively promoting sustainable traffic safety development, and providing valuable insights for targeted crash prevention and intelligent traffic safety management in urban areas.