Optimizing greywater treatment in green walls: A comparative analysis of recycled substrate materials

Abstract

The utilization of green walls for on-site greywater treatment in urban buildings has garnered significant attention in recent research, with substrates playing a vital role in treatment performance. The incorporation of recycled materials as substrates not only offers a cost-effective solution for greywater treatment, but also enhances sustainability by repurposing wastes. This study investigates the efficacy of three recycled substrates: alum sludge, garden compost, and a mixture of perlite-coconut fiber in three green wall systems for greywater treatment. Each substrate was allocated to a three-pot column. Comparative analysis revealed alum sludge (C3) and the coconut fiber-perlite mix (C1) achieving the highest chemical oxygen demand (COD) removal at 89.45 ± 2.92 % and 89.34 ± 2.47 %, respectively, with garden compost (C2) recording 67.98 ± 7.45 %. For total nitrogen (TN) removal, C2 achieved the lowest efficiency (49.27 ± 9.39 %), while C1 demonstrated 83.79 ± 10.45 %. Notably, C3 exhibited superior total phosphorus (TP) removal at 94.86 ± 1.87 %, compared to 52.07 ± 17.88 % for C1 and 24.90 ± 30.95 % for C2. Our findings demonstrate that substrate selection is crucial for optimizing both pollutant removal and plant health in green walls. The coconut fiber mix emerged as the most effective substrate, supporting robust plant growth and superior pollutant removal, particularly for nitrogen removal. In contrast, garden compost proved unsuitable, with minimal plant survival post-greywater introduction. Alum sludge showed significant promise, particularly for TP removal, reinforcing its effectiveness in green walls. These insights underscore the importance of substrate optimization in greywater treatment systems in urban environments.